Wealth of Ideas Newsletter

The Innovation Continuum: Putting Things in Perspective

At the recent NPE 2016 Conference in New York, a topic that came up repeatedly was the role that NPEs (or PAEs as the Federal Trade Commission calls them) play in the entire innovation experience – what we call in this article the “Innovation Continuum.” For the purpose of this article, we prefer the term “patent licensing company” to describe an enterprise that generates most of its income from licensing patents and other intellectual property.

The Innovation Continuum: Putting Things in Perspective

The Innovation Continuum: Putting Things in Perspective

At the recent NPE 2016 Conference in New York, a topic that came up repeatedly was the role that NPEs (or PAEs as the Federal Trade Commission calls them) play in the entire innovation experience – what we call in this article the “Innovation Continuum.” For the purpose of this article, we prefer the term “patent licensing company” to describe an enterprise that generates most of its income from licensing p

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Since the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) replaced the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (BPAI), a total of 2,600 petitions for Inter Partes Review were filed with the Board. Of these, 571 patents (22%) were invalidated as a result of all claims being ruled unpatentable. There were 114 patents that survived with only some claims ruled unpatentable.

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Since the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) replaced the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (BPAI), a total of 2,600 petitions for Inter Partes Review were filed with the Board. Of these, 571 patents (22%) were invalidated as a result of all claims being ruled unpatentable. There were 114 patents that survived with only some claims ruled unpatentable. And 107 patents survived with all claims intact.

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Since the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) replaced the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (BPAI), a total of 2,600 petitions for Inter Partes Review were filed with the Board. Of these, 571 patents (22%) were invalidated as a result of all claims being ruled unpatentable. There were 114 patents that survived with only some claims ruled unpatentable.

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Since the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) replaced the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (BPAI), a total of 2,600 petitions for Inter Partes Review were filed with the Board. Of these, 571 patents (22%) were invalidated as a result of all claims being ruled unpatentable. There were 114 patents that survived with only some claims ruled unpatentable.

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Since the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) replaced the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (BPAI), a total of 2,600 petitions for Inter Partes Review were filed with the Board. Of these, 571 patents (22%) were invalidated as a result of all claims being ruled unpatentable. There were 114 patents that survived with only some claims ruled unpatentable.

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Since the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) replaced the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (BPAI), a total of 2,600 petitions for Inter Partes Review were filed with the Board. Of these, 571 patents (22%) were invalidated as a result of all claims being ruled unpatentable. There were 114 patents that survived with only some claims ruled unpatentable.

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Since the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) replaced the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (BPAI), a total of 2,600 petitions for Inter Partes Review were filed with the Board. Of these, 571 patents (22%) were invalidated as a result of all claims being ruled unpatentable. There were 114 patents that survived with only some claims ruled unpatentable.

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Out of 2,600 Challenges, Patent Trial and Appeal Board Has Invalidated 571 Patents

Since the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) replaced the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (BPAI), a total of 2,600 petitions for Inter Partes Review were filed with the Board. Of these, 571 patents (22%) were invalidated as a result of all claims being ruled unpatentable. There were 114 patents that survived with only some claims ruled unpatentable.